Whitemantle Creek, Bute Inlet

2021: Local historian says recent Bute Inlet slide was one of many

While the largest slide in human memory occurred only months ago, local historian Judith Williams says Bute Inlet ‘lets loose’ all the time.

Collecting water, Raindrop Creek Falls, Bute Inlet – courtesy Judith Williams

Other times Bute let loose

The earliest information she has comes from the diary Robert Humphrey left, after he came to survey the area in 1861. 

“He describes, very elaborately, an avalanche coming down the Homathko side carrying stands of trees,” explained Williams. “So it’s nothing new, this is an area that lets loose all the time.” 

One of the better known slides disrupted plans for a Halloween party during the 1970’s. The residents of a logging camp, on the flank of the inlet, abruptly left after “everything moved.” 

Williams says landslides leave lots of scars on the landscape and “every so often you go up and there is a new one.” 

Collecting water at the Paradise River, 2011, Bute Inlet – courtesy Judith Williams

The most recent Bute Inlet slide

She finds the most recent slide especially interesting because of the possible link to Climate Change. The Homathko Icefield is shrinking and part of the glacier fell into Elliot Lake. A 100 foot high tidal wave crashed down Elliot Creek, into the Southgate River and into Bute Inlet.   

Williams suspects that some of the debris reached Cortes and Quadra Islands. She saw “a fair bit of wood in the water,” while crossing over on the ferry. 

“I was seeing things that looked kind of raw. The top was broken and shattered. The roots were broken. They hadn’t been bouncing around on the shore for a long time, where things get smoothed around,” she explained. “If you see a log like that, you know it has been washed out from somewhere.”

Connection to Bute Inlet

Judith Williams has a special connection to Bute Inlet.

“I’ve spent a lot of time: I’ve written two books centred on Bute. So I take a big interest and I’ve also travelled up there a number of times and even stayed up in the logging camp. So I feel very attached to it,” she explained. 

Some of the water samples – courtesy Judith Williams

Water collecting project

Williams started collecting water, from the eighteen rivers that empty into Bute Inlet, when there were plans to put run of river hydro projects into the area. The land is too steep to accommodate the 400 foot wide corridors that power lines need.

“Putting in any kind of apparatus for carrying power will lead to more and more avalanches, she said. 

If the power project had gone forward, Williams would have taken more samples to see what had changed.

Consequently, she has a water sample from Elliot Creek prior to the landslide and will soon be in possession of a current sample.

“We think we have lots of water because it rains all the time, but the big storages are in the glaciers. If we tamper with these, and climate is already tampering, we could find ourselves in an odd position. You can read articles and watch programs, these days, about how water is going to be the new oil – it is in such demand. We have it, we should look after it.”    

Links of interest:

Top photo credit: The would be developers of a run of the river project claimed there were no fish in Whitemantle Creek, Bute Inlet. So local guide Randy Killrean caught a trout, took this picture, and sent it to them – courtesy Randy Killrean/Judith Wilson.

This program was funded by a grant from the Community Radio Fund of Canada and the Government of Canada’s Local Journalism Initiative